Compare SN EN 12193:2019 with Other Standards
In this comparison, we will explore how SN EN 12193:2019 measures up against other relevant standards in the realm of artificial lighting for sports facilities. This analysis aims to assist stakeholders, including facility managers, architects, and lighting designers, in determining the most applicable standard for their specific needs.
Why compare SN EN 12193:2019 and compare SN EN 12193:2019 with other standards
The intent behind comparing SN EN 12193:2019 with other standards is primarily to clarify the best practices for artificial lighting in sports facilities. Professionals in the field—such as sports facility managers, architects, and engineers—are often tasked with ensuring compliance with relevant standards. By understanding the distinctions between SN EN 12193:2019 and other standards like EN 1838, they can make informed decisions that impact safety, performance, and user experience in sports environments. This comparison aids in identifying the most suitable standard for specific applications, ultimately guiding effective lighting design and implementation.
How SN EN 12193:2019 approaches the topic
SN EN 12193:2019 specifically addresses the requirements for artificial lighting in both indoor and outdoor sports facilities across Europe. It provides guidelines on various crucial aspects, including:
- Illuminance Levels: The standard sets specific illuminance levels tailored to different sports, ensuring optimal visibility and performance.
- Uniformity: It emphasizes the importance of uniform lighting to minimize shadows and enhance visibility.
- Glare Limitation: The standard outlines measures to control glare, enhancing comfort for athletes and spectators alike.
- Color Properties: Guidelines for color rendering and temperature ensure that lighting conditions are conducive to performance.
- Measurement Procedures: The standard details methods for assessing lighting parameters, ensuring compliance and effectiveness.
These criteria make SN EN 12193:2019 a comprehensive resource for ensuring high-quality lighting in sports venues.
How compare SN EN 12193:2019 with other standards approaches the topic
In contrast to SN EN 12193:2019, other standards—such as EN 1838—focus on emergency lighting specifically. EN 1838 outlines requirements for emergency lighting systems in various types of buildings, including sports facilities, emphasizing safety and visibility during emergencies. While it may touch on aspects of general lighting, its primary aim is to ensure that escape routes, exits, and areas of safety are adequately illuminated, thus prioritizing safety over performance in regular conditions. This distinction highlights the different focus areas of these standards, making it essential for stakeholders to select the appropriate standard based on their specific needs.
Side-by-side comparison
| Criteria | SN EN 12193:2019 | EN 1838 |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Focuses on artificial lighting in sports facilities | Focuses on emergency lighting in various facilities |
| Audience | Sports facility managers, architects, lighting designers | Building safety managers, architects, and facility operators |
| Cost/Effort | Moderate to high, depending on facility size and requirements | Generally lower; focuses on specific safety installations |
| Certification Mechanism | Compliance assessments based on illuminance and uniformity | Compliance checks for emergency lighting systems |
| Typical Use Cases | Indoor and outdoor sports events, training facilities | Emergency situations in public spaces and sports venues |
When to choose which
When determining which standard to adopt, consider the following recommendations:
- If you need comprehensive lighting solutions for sports facilities, choose SN EN 12193:2019 for optimal performance, visibility, and user satisfaction.
- If your focus is on safety and emergency preparedness, select EN 1838 to ensure that your lighting meets safety regulations for evacuation and emergency situations.
- For facilities that host both regular sports events and require emergency protocols, it may be necessary to implement both standards to cover all lighting aspects adequately.
- If you are looking for a standard that addresses common lighting issues in sports contexts, opt for SN EN 12193:2019 to navigate the complexities of sports lighting effectively.